Asus Zenbook S 16 review (2024 UM5606WA- AMD Ryzen AI 9 HX 370, Radeon 890M)

4 Comments

  1. NikoB

    August 1, 2024 at 2:46 pm

    From review:
    "Type: 10-bit with HDR500, 120 Hz;"
    "Black on max brightness: 0 cd/m2;"

    A review on another site (~20000:1) and the lack of an official "True HDR 400" label clearly indicates that there is no "infinite" black. It is worth drawing the readers' attention to this. This model, despite having AMOLED, to its shame, does not actually support the HDR10 standard.

    In general, as I already wrote on another site, it seems that buying new models makes sense compared to Zen4 Phoenix models (which, even after a year, to AMD's shame, are in real shortage even in the US / EU, if we take really adequate 15.6 "+ models), only with significantly less noise at the same performance as Zen4 Phoenix (which requires the correct power consumption profiles from the factory and the ability to flexibly configure the owner through the proprietary software for tuning PL1 / PL2 and other parameters) and at a comparable price, since the presence of an improved NPU unit gives practically nothing in practice to an ordinary buyer, and igpu, although improved (including due to a sharp improvement in efficiency (80% + of the theoretical bandwidth now, compared to 60-65% previously) of an outdated 128-bit memory controller with the same morally outdated lpddr5 7500 modules, but this is clearly not enough for igpu to reach the level of modern dgpu, without soldering in SoC VRAM of 512-1024 bits with a bandwidth of at least 300 GB/s. Increasing the number of shader and other units becomes pointless (as well as increasing the number of processor cores) with a small bandwidth – hence the race to increase the L1-L4 cache in order to somehow hide this key drawback of the x86 architecture – an outdated memory controller with a 128-bit bus more than 15 years old, against the background of progress with HBM3+ in server chips and a bandwidth of more than 1 TB/s.

    Actually, this is why there is again the same shameful lack of support for DP2.0+/UHBR20 for 8k monitors, which is declared only for Strix Halo with a 256-bit memory controller and lpddr5 8000 – the reason is still the same – insufficient bandwidth of the memory controller for such tasks.

    We are waiting with a delay, Strix Halo, although it will consume too much, even by the standards of previous architectures – consumption has increased from 54W to 70 on average, which indicates a clear slowdown in improvements in TSMC technological processes – each new improvement is given harder and harder to show the consumer a real increase in hardware performance and support for new technologies (like mass 8k panels, especially in monitors, where the ppi is clearly insufficient, which we have been waiting for more than 10 years) …

  2. Robert

    August 10, 2024 at 1:41 pm

    It not have numpad(!!!) but it 16 inches notebook. It not have full featured usb4 (with egpu support). Sorry, but these late 2024 asus notebooks are not looks nice for me. Even with hx370 platform, just will looking for another brand.

  3. Andrew

    September 15, 2024 at 3:33 pm

    I’ve been looking into getting the new Asus Zenbook S16 and noticed something odd. The 1TB SSD version is only about $5 less than the 2TB version. I’m curious as to why the price difference is so small. Is the 2TB SSD somehow slower or lower quality than the 1TB SSD, or is there another reason behind this minimal price gap? Would appreciate any insights! Thanks!

    • Andrei Girbea

      September 16, 2024 at 4:19 pm

      Shouldn't be any slower. Probably some sales offer on the 2TB model?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *